A Conservative Mother’s Complaint To Her Daughter’s Middle School Teacher

its all our fault

Mrs. XXX,

I have just finished skimming Bobbie’s take home paper called ‘The Disappearing Rainforests’ and I can honestly say that I have never read a worst case of liberal propaganda in my life.  When did it become the job of our educators to give such unsubstantiated opinions as the ones delivered in this paper?  When did it become standard policy to state a mere opinion as fact to the impressionable minds of thirteen year old’s?  Allow me to give you but a few examples:

  •     “Rainforests are being destroyed because the value of rainforest land is perceived as only the value of its timber by short sighted governments, multinational logging companies, and land owners.

I would ask for some kind of legitimate proof for this outlandish statement, but I won’t bother as it is clearly written by a liberal propagandist and can not survive even the most cursory test for scholarly accuracy.

  •     “Every time a rainforest medicine man dies, it is as if a library has burned down.”

Is this just a small bit of exaggeration?  Really?  A library?  What, then, if an American surgeon died?

  •     “Fewer rainforests mean less rain, less oxygen to breath, and increased threat from global warming.”

This one is so chock full of amazing assertions, I must demand the proof for them.  Less rain? Really?  Considering that Global warming is not a proven fact and merely a theory which weakens by the day, I would say the cause and effect must also be questioned.  Further, I would like to see how oxygen will simply disappear from the earth because the rain forest is being cut down.  Did ALL plant life disappear with the rainforest?  To my knowledge, there is no notable lack of oxygen even though the paper claims that we have already cut down most of ALL forests, let alone the rain forest, from the earth’s surface!  I’m still breathing.  These are outrageous claims, completely lacking in any kind of scholarly science.  And yet, they are taught as fact to all children?

  •     “Were we Americans any different with our own colonization, decimating the North American Indian tribes?  Like Brazil, we sent out a call to the world that America had land for the landless in an effort to increase colonization of our country AT THE EXPENSE OF OUR INDIGENOUS TRIBES.”

Well, that is the most unusual rewriting of our Statue of Liberty’s call to the world I have ever read- I never knew it was a ‘call to colonize our land in order to destroy the American Indian’!  Well, you learn something new everyday!  I thought the ‘call’ we sent out to the world was:

    “Give me your tired, your poor,

    Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free;

    The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,

    Send these, the homeless,

    Tempest-tossed to me

    I lift my lamp beside the golden door

Gee, and here I used to be proud of that call!  No more!

  •  “But who is really to blame?  Consider what we industrialized AMERICANS have done to our own homeland.  We converted 90 % of N. America’s virgin forests into firewood, furniture, railroad ties, and paper. ”  This goes on to excuse the actual countries who are actually cutting down the rainforests and then says, “much of the pressures on their remaining rainforests comes from SERVICING the needs and markets for wood products in industrialized countries that have already depleted their own natural resources.  Industrialized countries would not be buying rainforest hardwoods and timber had we not cut down our own trees long ago, nor would poachers in the Amazon jungle be SLAUGHTERING jaguar, ocelot, caiman, and otter if WE did not provide lucrative markets for their skins in Berlin, Paris and Tokyo.”

I’m sorry, but are creating a special voting group here?  WE are to blame for those countries’ decisions?  Really?  Did we force them to cut them down?  Is our military down there with our tanks and soldiers?  I thought our governmental authority ended at our own borders.  Call me naive!  In addition, the assertion that America is only needing Amazon wood because we so lazily used up OUR wood is plain… stupid & not factual.  We industrialized before the Amazon countries did.  We have many more people than they have.  Our needs came earlier and with more force then did theirs.  If we had NOT used our resources, we could not have grown to be the industrial giant we have become.  We would NOT be the America that now is the most powerful, rich nation in the world, now would we?  So, it would be safe to conclude that had we never used those ‘virgin’ forests (I like that clever phrase- thus negating to the need to mention that we have NEW, carefully managed forests galore), we would not even BE in the situation where you, Ms. XXX, would have the nice school, the nice job and the nice country in which to brainwash my kids like this.

    Never have I seen such one sided, overly emotional & exaggerated wording to evoke the most anger/hated at/of  America as possible from our students!  Not only is this a completely unproven set of opinions  but it lacks all standards of scholarly rigor!  This is emotional tripe- this is an opinion piece with some raw data barely sprinkled in.  I am outraged, to say the least, at this content.    But my favorite is yet to come:

  •     “Logging tropical hardwoods like teak, mahogany, rosewood, and other timber for furniture, building materials, charcoal, and other wood products is big business and big profits.  Several species of tropical hardwoods are imported by developed countries, including the UNITED STATES, just to build coffins that are then buried or burned.”

Yes, that is my very favorite.  Of course, this unmitigated b.s. continues right to the very end of this incredible paper- but we will stop here as I believe my point has been made.  The overarching theme of this … paper… is to communicate the following to the students:

  1.     America is deeply to blame for the loss of the rainforest.
  2.     America is greedy and has wasted all of its natural resources
  3.     America is now depleted of its own wood and resources and is now stealing it from these poor nations.
  4.     America is forcing these nations to cut down their rain forests.
  5.     America is responsible for less oxygen and global warming.
  6.     America intentionally destroyed the American Indian.
  7.     America is intentionally destroying the Amazon Indians.
  8.     Being an indigenous Indian is superior to being a modern person who lives with technology and modern medicine.
  9.     Modern man should be sacrificed so that indigenous Indians can remain the same as they were.
  10.     Indigenous Indians should never modernize- that would be an evil thing.
  11.     The reason to keep the rainforest around is for the potential medicinal value of its plants.  However, the reason the rainforest is being destroyed is for stupid things like modern medicine.
  12.     If American had never begun, we would never have used our resources and so would never have ruined the world.
  13.     It would have been better if America had never become a great, powerful nation.
  14.     If the rain forest goes away, the world will stop breathing.  Global warming will kill us all.

The Amazon Rainforest debate is MUCH more complex than this idiotic paper would have it.  It presents a decidedly liberal, democratic, progressive bent.  Why?  Where is the other side of the argument?  I promise you  that there is one!

Further, I have taken great umbrage over the book list you provided for Bobbie in the supposed pursuit of ‘multiculturalism’.  Multiculturalism is the idea (with which I totally disagree) that various immigrant cultures in a country can remain distinct and separate from the main culture and/or other ‘mini’ cultures and still co-exist in peace and harmony.  It is the antithesis of the ‘melting pot’ theory with which we all grew up.  Whether or not I happen to agree with such an idea is irrelevant.  Multiculturalism IS that cultures, races, languages, styles, etc, can and should coexist in harmony within a single national border.  Why, then, is your book list 100% geared toward the teaching of white racism and class warfare?  Every book is either about how the white race has done terrible evil to other races or about how the super rich have ‘stolen’ from the poor.  You told the class that these books would, ‘Truly anger you… but that is what they SHOULD do!”  Really?  Really?  You think your job is to anger the students in your class toward the white race and the rich in the world?  Is THAT your job, Ms. XXX?  I thought it was to present data to my child.  And if you must put an opinion on that raw data, to present multiple sides EQUALLY.

What is going on at Evergreen Middle School?  Are you knowingly and immorally brainwashing the next generation of children to be liberal voters?  Because that is the only rational conclusion to which I can come.  No child  whose parents aren’t closely watching will come out of Mrs. XXX’s class with any sense of national pride- that’s for sure.  And not one of them will come out a political conservative- of that, I am 100% sure.  And if they are white, they will feel like they are evil and should be guilty.  If they are any other race, they will believe that all whites hate them and will always hate them (how sad).

I think not.  If you want to teach on cultures, then teach on cultures- positively, if you want to produce a generation with positive race attitudes.  Otherwise, you had better change that class name to ‘White Racism and How the Rich Took Advantage of Everyone Else.”

Again.  There are many sides to a story, Ms. XXX.  Why is only the Liberal, Progressive, Democrat side being shoved mercilessly down the children’s throats?  Do you have the nerve to tell me that you are also presenting the Conservative viewpoint on these subjects?  Or do you dare to tell me that you have presented all the facts- or that the facts MUST equal the opinions presented in your class?  Would you call half of America … lacking in any factual basis for their belief system?  I would like to hear your response, Ms. XXX.

Where are the Black success stories in America?  Where are the books that show that the American Black Person is the richest Black Person in the entire world?  Do we not now have a Black president?  Did we not come far from those days of the KKK?  Where are the books showing how the Japanese, whom had originally been unjustly put into labor camps in WWII, have now become among the richest people in America- in the world- this is a testament to America, is it not???  Where are the books that show how beautifully our culture has become so racially intermixed that our children no longer look anything like they did in the 1950’s?   I, personally, am a product of a White American and native Korean wedding.  By now, the mixing of races is so common that no even notices. Where are the books that praise how our unique blend of races and cultures produced the most innovative people on earth- leading directly to its dominance in the world today? How about how many women we now have a CEO’s, millionaires, billionaires, politicians and world leaders?   Isn’t that something to celebrate?   Where are the books that show this progress??  Why are they ALL about negative race relations?  Again, that is a political talking point for DEMOCRATS and liberals.  Why are you only showing one side of the political spectrum, Ms. XXX?

And please do not play coy with me.  If you would like, allow me to present my question this way, “Why is only one perspective so wholly presented to our children?  So much so that I have to doubt how they could even become aware that there are other perspectives on these issues in America and the world?”

Enough.  Suffice it to say that I am disgusted by your choice of books and papers for the children.  Unless you were forced to use these materials by WA State or Washington D.C., I put the blame squarely upon your shoulders.  Shame on you.  And shame on Evergreen Middle School for having so little oversight, so little responsibility for scholarly standards and so little desire to represent the real world of opinions to our children.

Susan H. Shannon

16 comments

  1. well what do you see as the reason all the worlds rainforests are being wiped out? Doesn’t it boil down to worshipping Mammon..$$$$ Corporate greed? A lot of forests are wiped out to eg make room for cattle ranches..for hamburger meat ..America is the home of McDonalds

    • There are many reasons for the destruction of the rain forest. But ultimately, those countries are the ones who bear the responsibility to take care of them. No one is forcing them to sell those products. THEY want to enrich their countries by using their resources. How is America forcing them to sell? We provide the demand, sure. But where is the gun to their head? They can say no. That simple. Just as we say ‘no’ to loggers who want a swing at our national treasures. It is possible, ya know. The only way anyone else (other than the government that owns them) can take care of those forests and make decisions for the management of those forests is if we somehow gain the AUTHORITY over those rain forests. As long as those nations remain sovereign, we will never have this authority. And THIS points to why the Progressives harp on it so much. It is being used to manipulate young people into agreeing with the end to national sovereignty in favor of a world government. Of course, this new world government is sold as some kind of benevolent force along the lines of the Federation in Star Trek- a new Utopia that will save all the world resources, share all the food, provide all the clean water and spread all the money around so that there will be no more poor people. Sadly, concentrated power never works that way. The more power that concentrates into fewer hands equals increased tyranny. This is why socialist countries ALWAYS produce tyrants. If you think America is a tyrant, just you wait until we get ONE government over the whole world. With all the armies and all the communication and all the technology at their disposal.

      Liberals like you always think that taking guns and power away from people means that they will only be taken from STUPID people like me. But you are very, very mistaken. Power is taken from ALL the people the day it is taken from one upstanding citizen. I can promise you that I am the biggest goody two shoes that ever lived. Yet, I am viewed as a dangerous person by our government- probably by you too. Isn’t that funny?

      Liberals like you never consider the fact that those army troops won’t give a damn who you voted for when they come to seize your home because it is just too big for a family of your size. Or when they bring a big moving truck filled with the belongings of illegal immigrants that don’t have a home and tell you that it is only ‘fair’ that you should share your home with them. For the greater good.

      Liberals like you think only people like me will be affected by these new laws that repress free speech. But you are wrong. There will come a day when YOU disagree vehemently against what some leader does and you will then worry about being spied upon. You will worry about police officers that have little hand held devices with your photo, name, address and new status as a ‘Anti- Government Activist’ because you dared to write a nasty letter to your Congressman. And these cops are stationed outside of the school where your child attends. Then, YOU will worry that you won’t be able to get your child should any emergency arise. Because those cops will stop you due to this new category that Eric Holder just created for you.

      That is when dreamy eyed, America hating, uber cool youngster like you will think, too late, “Hey, I wasn’t SERIOUS about all that stuff I said! I thought the Constitution was unbreakable! I didn’t think this could ever really happen! I was just trying to look cool in front of my friends! I never thought anyone would take me seriously when I said I hated America!” Well, it will be too late then, Cassie. Too late. Because all those little levers you pulled on election day? They MATTERED. And they changed the world. YOUR world.

      • Oops..Woa!…I’m not a “liberal” (!!!), and I’m not young either…Woa you’re getting carried away..(.I think your’e talking about Agenda 21.)..I’m coming from a totally different place..1) wiping out rainforests is..not ok. And, it’s always for $$$. 2) I feel that OTHER things taught at school should raise your ire far more..such as sex education..& corrupting of our young. I’ve recently read that in UK sex ed will now discuss “pornography”( !!) I don’t live in either USA or UK but I follow the trends there because this global “contamination” of evil is spreading. I guess that was the point – there are far worse things about schooling we should be worried about.

      • Ah. Well, I agree with sex ed and a slew of other things. But my ire over the rainforest studies wasn’t teaching about the rainforests. It was the attempt to create a mindset in children that 1) America is bad. 2) Capitalism is to blame for poverty in other countries 3) We have global problems that require global solutions- and the only way to IMPLEMENT Global solutions is with the might of a global government. This, to me, ranks very high on the danger list for our future voters. But I agree about those other topics as well.

  2. I think people need to realize that the earth is one of God’s gifts to His people. He told us to take over the earth and conquer the land and have dominion over over all other living things. When we lose sight of that, we start believing the lie that we will run out of what we need to survive. I am certain that God has delighted in the many ways man has discovered to use the resources of the earth. He won’t let us run out, but He never intended for it all to last forever.

    • Kathy, that is a fact. The liberal mindset is to make human beings a creature subservient to ‘Mother Earth’, thereby resurrecting the ancient rites of Mother worship. It is pure nonsense. So-called atheists want to believe that history could have gone otherwise or that humans today should die or be coerced into sterilization so that Mother Earth can ‘survive’. This shows not only a lack of faith in God, but in mankind as well. The sad fact is that even if God didn’t step in someday, mankind would destroy itself through nuclear warfare far before it would ‘run out’ of natural resources. Nature has a way of SELF correcting overpopulation. Tyranny is not needed.

  3. I appreciate this mother’s views…and the way she respectfully expressed them. She is obviously part of the solution. I dread the fact that my grandchildren are going to be subjected to the Godless, liberal progressive ideologies that have turned our public education institutions into indoctrination centers. I will do all in my power to undermine these progressive ideologies in their minds, and show them the other side of so-called “facts” that will be drilled into their minds and hearts by the Godless, immoral, and politically driven indoctrination agents known as public school “teachers!”

  4. There is a video on YouTube that shows what Common Core teaches in it’s liberal arts program to 1st graders. It purposely teaches children to use anger words, and to write based on emotions. There’s also another video linked to it that has a psychologist talking about how if you force young children to always use emotions & anger words, it is extremely damaging to their brains and they will not mature out of their primordial response system. It’s very interesting and extremely scary if it’s being done on purpose.

    • I SAW that video! I thought of the EXACT same thing when I read this paper. I thought, “See? They are giving an example of that kind of ‘activism’ language. So sad to see what the state of our once great educational system has become.

      • The public schools in this country were originally intended to teach our children the Gospel of Jesus Christ and biblical principles. Oh, how far we have fallen! Now we must all bear the fruits of our tolerance…no, the complete acceptance of…sin and Godlessness. May God have mercy on us all, and forgive us ALL for not doing more…for not standing up and saying, “ENOUGH!”

    • Can you leave the link to this particular video please? There are so many of them on Common Core that I want to be sure I’m watching the one your speaking of. Thanks.

    • Oh my goodness! And that is exactly what adult Liberals are and how they behave: overly emotional, their world-view based on opinions and emotions… so Common Core starts ’em young!

Please join the conversation! All comments are monitored, so if you have a private note you wish to leave, just say so. Also, all profane or unhelpful comments will be deleted. Thank you!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s